Detectives and Criminal Investigators: Job Description and Salary

Table of Contents

Detectives and Criminal Investigators Overview

Detectives and criminal investigators operate in diverse industries, ranging from law enforcement and government to insurance and technology. Many also work as independent contractors, particularly in background investigations.

What Is a Detective?

Detectives are specialized law enforcement officers who handle complex criminal cases, often involving serious crimes such as homicides and missing persons. They play a crucial role in solving these cases by collecting evidence, conducting interviews, and piecing together the details to uncover the truth.

Detective Job Description

Detectives are specialized law enforcement officers responsible for investigating crimes, collecting evidence, and solving cases. They play a critical role in ensuring public safety and bringing criminals to justice. Detectives work for local, state, or federal law enforcement agencies and may also be employed in the private sector.

Detective’s Primary Responsibilities

Gathering Facts and Evidence: Detectives meticulously collect and analyze physical and digital evidence from crime scenes.
Inspecting Records: They review criminal records, financial statements, and other documents to find clues.
Interviewing Witnesses: Conducting detailed interviews with witnesses, victims, and suspects to gather critical information.
Conducting Surveillance: Following suspects and conducting stake-outs to observe their activities and gather intelligence.
Analyzing Clues: Researching all aspects of a case, connecting various pieces of evidence to form a coherent picture.

Case Assignment and Management

Assignment of Cases: Cases are typically assigned based on a detective’s expertise, seniority, and track record. For example, complex homicide cases are often given to detectives with the highest success rates.
Case Progression: Detectives work on cases until they are resolved or until it becomes clear that further investigation is not feasible. If a case remains unsolved for an extended period, it may be reassigned or closed.

Educational and Training Requirements

The educational requirements for detectives and criminal investigators vary by position:

High School Diploma: Entry-level positions may only require a high school diploma.
College Degree: Many positions prefer candidates with a college degree.
Specialized Training: Positions often require specialized law enforcement training.

Those with the highest qualifications will find the best job opportunities at local, state, and federal law enforcement agencies, as well as in private sector companies and corporations.

What Do Detectives and Criminal Investigators Do?

Detectives and criminal investigators often have overlapping roles, and the terms are sometimes used interchangeably. Both careers focus on protecting lives and property, but they can differ significantly based on the types of crimes they investigate.

Primary Responsibilities

Whether dealing with crime or fraud, detectives and criminal investigators employ similar techniques to solve cases:

Researching Criminal Files: Reviewing past cases and criminal records to find connections and patterns.
Interviewing Witnesses: Gathering information from witnesses, victims, and suspects to build a comprehensive understanding of the case.
Investigating Leads: Following up on tips and leads to uncover new information and evidence.
Inspecting Crime Scenes: Carefully examining crime scenes to collect physical evidence and reconstruct events.
Examining Evidence: Analyzing various types of evidence, including physical, digital, and forensic, to identify perpetrators and build cases.

Distinct Roles and Crime Types

Detectives: Typically work within police departments, focusing on specific types of crimes such as homicides, robberies, and violent offenses. They may be assigned to specialized units like narcotics, gang activity, or sexual crimes.

Criminal Investigators: Often work for federal agencies, insurance companies, or private firms, handling cases related to fraud, financial crimes, cybercrime, and white-collar crimes. They may also conduct background checks and surveillance.

What Is a Criminal Investigator?

A criminal investigator handles a wide variety of cases, including fraud, theft, and terrorism. They work to protect both lives and property, whether personal or commercial.

Scope of Work

Case Variety: Criminal investigators deal with diverse cases ranging from financial crimes and property theft to serious offenses like terrorism and cybercrime.
Protecting Property: Their work extends to protecting both physical and intellectual property, ensuring the safety and integrity of commercial and private assets.

Employment Sectors

Law Enforcement Agencies: Criminal investigators can work for local, state, and federal law enforcement agencies, handling cases that require in-depth investigation.
Private Sector: They are often employed by insurance companies to validate claims or by corporations and tech companies to safeguard assets and intellectual property.
Independent Contractors: Many criminal investigators operate as independent contractors, offering their services to private clients for various investigative needs.

Detective vs. Investigator: Understanding the Differences

The terms “detective” and “investigator” are often used interchangeably, but there are distinct differences between these roles, especially regarding their responsibilities, work environments, and areas of focus.

Role and Responsibilities

Detectives:

Law Enforcement Focus: Detectives typically work for local, state, or federal law enforcement agencies. They are responsible for investigating serious crimes such as homicides, missing persons, and violent offenses.
Crime Scene Work: Detectives spend significant time at crime scenes, gathering evidence, interviewing witnesses, and piecing together the events leading to the crime.
Specialized Units: Many detectives are assigned to specialized units such as narcotics, gang activity, or sexual crimes, focusing on specific types of criminal activity.
Arrest Authority: Detectives have the legal authority to make arrests and often work closely with uniformed police officers.

Criminal Investigators:

Broader Scope: Criminal investigators may work for law enforcement agencies but are also commonly employed in the private sector. They handle a wide range of cases, including fraud, theft, cybercrime, and terrorism.
Private Sector Roles: In the private sector, investigators often work for insurance companies, corporations, or as independent contractors. They may investigate internal theft, conduct background checks, or protect intellectual property.
Expert Testimony: Criminal investigators frequently provide expert testimony in court, presenting findings and evidence collected during investigations.
Limited Arrest Authority: Unless they work under a law enforcement agency, criminal investigators usually do not have the authority to make arrests.

Work Environment

Detectives:

Law Enforcement Agencies: Most detectives are employed by municipal police departments, state police, or federal agencies like the FBI.
Structured Hierarchy: Detectives typically follow a structured chain of command within their departments, reporting to superior officers and working in teams.

Criminal Investigators:

Diverse Settings: Criminal investigators can be found in various settings, from corporate offices and insurance firms to private investigative services.
Independent Work: Many criminal investigators work independently, offering their services to clients on a case-by-case basis.

Education and Training

Detectives:

Law Enforcement Training: Detectives usually start as uniformed officers and advance through the ranks. They undergo extensive law enforcement training and may attend specialized courses.
Field Experience: Practical experience in law enforcement is crucial, with many detectives having years of experience before moving into investigative roles.

Criminal Investigators:

Varied Backgrounds: Criminal investigators may come from diverse educational backgrounds, including criminal justice, forensic science, or business.
Specialized Knowledge: Investigators often have specialized knowledge relevant to their field, such as cyber security for those dealing with cybercrime or accounting for those investigating financial fraud.

When Do Detectives Get Involved?

Detectives typically become involved in criminal cases when specialized investigative skills are required beyond the scope of routine patrol duties. Their involvement is crucial in solving complex crimes and ensuring justice is served. Here are the key scenarios when detectives are called upon:

Serious Crimes

Homicides: Detectives are called in to investigate murders, where they meticulously examine crime scenes, collect evidence, and interview witnesses to solve the case and identify the perpetrator.
Violent Crimes: In cases of violent crimes such as assaults, armed robberies, and sexual assaults, detectives work to gather evidence, identify suspects, and build cases for prosecution.
Missing Persons: When someone goes missing under suspicious circumstances, detectives are tasked with finding the individual and determining if a crime has occurred.

Complex Investigations

Fraud and Financial Crimes: Detectives with expertise in financial matters investigate complex fraud cases, embezzlement, and other financial crimes, often involving detailed examination of financial records.
Cybercrime: With the rise of digital crime, detectives specializing in cybercrime investigate hacking, identity theft, and other online criminal activities, requiring advanced technical skills.
Organized Crime: Detectives investigate organized crime activities, including drug trafficking, human trafficking, and gang-related crimes, often working in specialized units.

Situations Requiring Specialized Skills

Forensics and Evidence Collection: When a case requires detailed forensic analysis or specialized evidence collection techniques, detectives are brought in to apply their expertise.
Undercover Operations: Detectives conduct undercover operations to infiltrate criminal organizations or gather intelligence on criminal activities, requiring specialized training and skills.
Surveillance: For ongoing investigations, detectives may conduct surveillance operations to monitor suspects and gather critical information without alerting them.

Legal and Administrative Requests

Court Orders and Warrants: Detectives may be involved in executing search warrants and court orders, ensuring that legal procedures are followed, and evidence is collected lawfully.
Interagency Collaboration: Detectives often work with other law enforcement agencies, such as the FBI or state police, on cases that cross jurisdictional boundaries or require federal involvement.

Responsibilities of Detectives and Criminal Investigators

The responsibilities of detectives and criminal investigators vary based on their work environment and specific job roles. Here’s a detailed overview:

Law Enforcement Detectives

Case Focus: Detectives working for local, state, or federal law enforcement agencies often handle serious crimes such as homicides and missing person cases.
Evidence Collection: They gather and analyze evidence from crime scenes, including physical evidence and digital data.
Witness Interviews: Conducting interviews with witnesses, victims, and suspects to obtain critical information for the case.
Surveillance and Undercover Work: Performing surveillance operations and participating in undercover assignments to gather information and observe suspects.
Court Testimony: Providing expert testimony in court, presenting evidence and detailed reports to support prosecutions.

Criminal Investigators

Case Variety: Criminal investigators may work on a range of cases including theft, fraud, cybersecurity breaches, and terrorism.
Collaboration: Often collaborating with police and other law enforcement agencies on complex investigations.
Private Sector Roles: In the private sector, they may be employed by insurance companies to validate claims, or by corporations to protect intellectual and physical property.
Specialized Investigations: Engaging in specialized investigations such as financial crime, public corruption, organized crime, and drug trafficking.

Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) Agents

National Threats: FBI agents handle cases involving national security threats, such as terrorism and espionage.
White-Collar Crime: Investigating business records and conducting surveillance to uncover white-collar crimes like fraud and embezzlement.
Diverse Case Load: Working on various types of criminal activity including bank robberies, public corruption, organized crime, and cybercrime.
Advanced Techniques: Utilizing advanced investigative techniques, such as undercover operations and electronic surveillance.

Record-Keeping and Court Evidence

Detailed Documentation: Keeping meticulous records of all investigative activities and evidence collected.
Courtroom Role: Providing crucial evidence and firsthand accounts in court, which are essential for the prosecution of criminal cases.

Key Skills

Analytical Skills: Ability to analyze complex information and draw logical conclusions.
Attention to Detail: Meticulous attention to detail in evidence collection and documentation.
Communication: Strong communication skills for interviewing and court testimony.
Technical Proficiency: Familiarity with forensic tools, databases, and surveillance equipment.

Job Risks for Detectives and Criminal Investigators

Exposure to Crime Scenes

Detectives and criminal investigators frequently visit crime scenes, where they encounter distressing and traumatic sights, including assault, murder, and accidental death. This exposure can have a significant emotional impact, requiring resilience and coping strategies.

Dealing with Violent Criminals

Working with violent criminals is a common aspect of the job. Detectives and criminal investigators often find themselves in threatening situations, where they must exercise caution and employ tactical skills to ensure their safety.

Interacting with Traumatized Individuals

Detectives and criminal investigators regularly interact with people who have experienced traumatic events. This includes victims, witnesses, and families affected by crimes, who may be undergoing severe physical or mental suffering. Effective communication and empathy are crucial in these interactions.

Stress and Physical Demands

The nature of investigative work can be extremely stressful and physically demanding. Detectives and criminal investigators often work long hours, handle multiple cases simultaneously, and face high-pressure situations that require quick decision-making.

Mental Health Impact

The cumulative effect of constant exposure to crime, violence, and human suffering can take a toll on mental health. Detectives and criminal investigators are at risk of developing issues such as PTSD, anxiety, and depression. To mitigate these risks, law enforcement agencies provide special training to handle extreme scenarios and offer various medical and mental health resources.

How Many Hours Do Detectives and Criminal Investigators Work?

Standard Work Hours

For detectives and criminal investigators working with law enforcement agencies, the typical workweek is 40 hours. However, paid overtime is common due to the demanding nature of the job.

Varying Shifts and On-Call Duties

Varying Shifts: Detectives and criminal investigators often work varying shifts to provide protection around the clock. This can include night shifts, weekends, and holidays.
Long Hours During Investigations: When working on active investigations, they may be required to work long hours to gather evidence, interview witnesses, and follow leads.
On-Call Requirements: Detectives and criminal investigators may need to stay on call, especially if a case is nearing a critical point. This means they must be ready to respond to new developments at any time.

FBI Agents

Work Hours: FBI agents typically work at least 50 hours per week and are on call 24/7, seven days a week. This high demand reflects the critical nature of their work in national security and federal investigations.
Authority and Preparedness: When working under the auspices of law enforcement, detectives and criminal investigators may need to exercise their authority and remain armed even when off duty.
Travel and Relocation: Federal agents, including those in the FBI, may be required to travel extensively, sometimes on short notice, and may need to relocate multiple times throughout their careers to various assignments and offices.

How To Become a Detective or Criminal Investigator

Meet Basic Qualifications:

Age and Citizenship: Ensure you are at least 21 years old and a U.S. citizen.

Complete Basic Education:

High School Diploma: Obtain a high school diploma or equivalent.

Pursue Higher Education (if required):

College Coursework: Consider completing one or two years of college coursework.
College Degree: Earn a degree in criminal justice, police science, or a related field for better job prospects.

Develop Additional Skills:

Foreign Language: Learn at least one foreign language to enhance your application for federal positions.
Physical Fitness: Engage in regular physical training and participate in sports to build stamina and agility.

Apply for Law Enforcement Positions:

Research Agencies: Identify and apply to local, state, or federal law enforcement agencies.
Civil Service Exams: Prepare for and pass any required civil service exams.

Attend a Law Enforcement Academy:

Academy Training: Graduate from a law enforcement agency’s training academy, which includes physical, legal, and practical training.

Gain On-the-Job Training:

Field Training: Complete on-the-job training under the supervision of experienced officers.

Pursue Continuous Education:

Additional Courses: Take additional law enforcement courses to enhance skills and career prospects.
Specialized Training: Seek specialized training in areas such as cybercrime, forensic investigation, or financial crime.

Apply for Federal Positions (optional):

Federal Agencies: Apply for positions at federal agencies like the FBI, which require extensive experience and specialized skills.
Be Prepared for Relocation: Be ready to travel extensively and relocate as needed.

Consider Private Sector Opportunities:

Insurance Firms and Corporations: Apply to private sector companies that require investigators to handle fraud, theft, and security breaches.
Independent Contractor: Build a solid track record and consider working as an independent investigator.

Maintain Personal Qualifications:

Integrity and Responsibility: Demonstrate honesty, integrity, and a strong sense of responsibility.
Interpersonal Skills: Cultivate strong communication skills and enjoy interacting with the public.

Undergo Evaluations:

Physical Examinations: Pass physical exams testing hearing, vision, agility, and strength.
Psychological Evaluations: Complete psychological evaluations and personality tests.

Advance Your Career:

Continued Training: Engage in continuous training in firearms, use-of-force policies, communication skills, and self-defense tactics.
Pursue Specializations: Specialize in advanced areas to open up further career opportunities.

Detective and Criminal Investigator Salary

As of May 2021, the median annual salary for detectives and criminal investigators in law enforcement is around $66,000, or $31.74 per hour. However, this salary can vary greatly depending on the branch of work, qualifications, experience, and location. As of February 2022, the average median annual salary for a homicide detective is $75,800, with the lowest 10 percent earning less than $50,000, and the highest 10 percent earning more than $111,000 annually.

For detectors and criminal investigators specializing in fraud, the median annual salary is around $64,100 a year (as of May 2022), with the lowest 10 percent making less than $41,000 and the highest 10 percent making around $95,000 annually.

Additionally, some law enforcement agencies offer higher salaries for detectives who are bilingual or have college degrees. And as for other compensation, many law enforcement agencies provide extensive benefits, as well as the option to retire earlier than the norm.

Conclusion

Detective and criminal investigation work can provide a rewarding career, as long as you understand the responsibilities that these jobs entail. While criminal investigation requires highly specialized training, the good news is that job prospects are favorable for this field. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projects around 67,100 law enforcement job openings for police and detectives opening each year over the next decade, and this number doesn’t even include private sector positions. While it’s an exacting profession, the field of criminal investigation will always be in demand, with agencies and companies in both the public and private sector eager to accept new applicants each year.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions — FBI

Police and Detectives : Occupational Outlook Handbook: : U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (bls.gov)

Homicide Detective Salary | PayScale

Fraud Investigator Salary | PayScale